Pokémon S1E9: “The School of Hard Knocks” Review

“The School of Hard Knocks” is one of the weaker episodes of the early Pokémon series for me. The basic idea is interesting, but almost everyone in the episode manages to be irritating in one way or another.

The episode takes Ash, Misty, and Brock to Pokémon Technical Institute, an elite school where students receive formal education and training to become Pokémon Trainers. Unlike Ash, who is working his way toward the Pokémon League by collecting Gym Badges, students from Pokémon Tech can qualify for the League through the school’s program.

In theory, this creates an interesting contrast with what we’ve seen so far. Ash is an inexperienced Trainer who has been learning by actually traveling through the world and battling other Trainers. Pokémon Tech represents the opposite approach: formal education, academic knowledge, testing, and an environment where students are expected to demonstrate that they understand the technical side of Pokémon training.

Unfortunately, the people inhabiting that environment aren’t particularly pleasant.

The episode is essentially built around bullying and status. Students look down on anyone they consider inferior, people constantly try to demonstrate how smart or knowledgeable they are, and there is a lot of posturing. Even the students who aren’t outright bullying someone seem to be compensating for something or trying to prove that they’re better than everyone else.

That makes the entire school feel unpleasant.

Giselle is probably the clearest example. She’s an intelligent and capable student, but her confidence quickly crosses into arrogance. She looks down on Ash and Misty because they don’t attend Pokémon Tech and assumes that formal education makes her superior to them.

There is an interesting idea buried underneath that characterization. Knowledge is valuable, and Pokémon Trainers can certainly benefit from studying rather than simply relying on instinct. But the episode makes it pretty clear that academic knowledge doesn’t automatically make someone a good Trainer.

That’s something Ash has demonstrated repeatedly in the series already. He may not know nearly as much as he should, but he has gained practical experience through actually traveling, battling, and interacting with Pokémon.

The bullying storyline involving Joe is where the episode becomes particularly uncomfortable. Joe is struggling academically and is treated poorly by the other students because of it. The whole situation reinforces the episode’s central theme, but I found it difficult to enjoy because so many of the characters are unpleasant.

Ash naturally takes issue with the way Joe is being treated. That is consistent with the version of Ash we’ve seen developing over the previous episodes. He might be inexperienced and occasionally arrogant himself, but he has repeatedly demonstrated that he cares about people and Pokémon.

There’s also a nice continuation of the show’s willingness to compare different approaches to Pokémon training. We’ve already seen A.J.’s extremely demanding physical training in the previous episode. Here, we get the opposite extreme: Trainers who have received extensive formal education but may not necessarily have the practical experience needed to handle real situations.

Unfortunately, I don’t think the episode handles that contrast as effectively as “The Path to the Pokémon League” handled A.J.’s philosophy.

The most interesting part of the episode for me is actually the revelation involving Team Rocket.

We learn that Jessie and James attended Pokémon Tech. This is a school apparently aimed at wealthy students, which raises some interesting questions about their backgrounds. The two of them somehow managed to achieve the school’s worst entrance-exam score, which is a pretty spectacular achievement considering the environment they’re coming from.

It also provides one of the earliest hints that Jessie and James have a history that existed before Ash ever encountered them.

That’s particularly interesting because Team Rocket has mostly been presented as a trio of comedic villains. Suddenly we get a tiny glimpse into their lives before they became the people Ash knows. We don’t get much explanation yet, but knowing that they attended this elite school gives the characters a little more history.

Unfortunately, the episode doesn’t do much with that idea beyond the joke.

Final Thoughts

“The School of Hard Knocks” is a weaker episode compared with several of the episodes we’ve watched so far.

There are some genuinely good ideas here. The contrast between formal education and practical experience is interesting, the episode explores bullying, and the Pokémon Tech setting gives us a different perspective on how someone can become a Pokémon Trainer.

But I found almost everyone in the episode annoying. The students are either bullying someone, showing off, compensating for their shortcomings, or trying to establish their superiority. That makes the episode’s central environment difficult to enjoy.

The one thing that really caught my attention was the glimpse into Jessie and James’s history. Learning that Team Rocket’s two human members attended this elite school is a surprisingly interesting piece of background, particularly because the school appears to cater to wealthy families.

It doesn’t completely rescue the episode for me, but it does give it one of the more interesting pieces of world-building we’ve encountered so far.

Overall, this is an episode with some good ideas that doesn’t quite live up to them. After the character development and Gym adventures of the previous few episodes, “The School of Hard Knocks” feels like a step backward.